This past summer, the popular blogger Paul Skallas made a post titled “There Is No Town Dream.” Some of us, he writes, dream “the urban dream of the city with its friendships, hustle and bustle, career opportunities and romance prospects,” as well as its promise that “you can be young forever.” Others dream “the suburban dream of the high-efficiency sanctuary, a clean cul-de-sac, an attached garage, a manicured yard, and top-tier school districts designed for child-rearing.” A growing minority dream “the rural dream of lots of private space, and a total retreat from civilization. You and your ownership over nature.” But a small town “looks like the place you were stuck in. There is no aspirational archetype for the person who thrives in a town. No distinct look, no narrative that confers status.” Hence the dilapidated, superannuated, and increasingly hollowed-out condition of most such places today — at least if they don’t have a data center.
That Skallas is writing about the United States in particular may be too obvious to clarify. Yet the desperate condition of the American small town in reality does run rather counter to the assumptions produced by the veneration of the American small town as an idea, a sentiment powerful enough to seem more deeply rooted than it is. Though the U.S. has a long tradition of anti-urbanism, the small town has been at the center of American culture for less than a century, according to Miles Orvell’s The Death and Life of Main Street: Small Towns in American Memory, Space, and Community. In the nineteen-twenties, the humble commercial strip of the title was mercilessly satirized in the novels of Sinclair Lewis, Main Street and onward, as “an image of the dullness of provincial life,” but in the thirties, it came to stand for “the bedrock of American democracy.” Orvell pins this reversal to the Great Depression, an existential threat to the material foundations of both the American ideal and the American reality, quoting William Empson’s observation that “that the need to invent untroubled perfection always springs from anxiety.”
Befitting his apparently high status in the academic realm of American studies, Orvell shows somewhat less interest in the Main Streets that actually exist in the U.S. than in Main Street as it manifests in literary and intellectual history. Among the works he cites are two books by Sherwood Anderson that reflect the perceptions of small towns before and after the Depression. Though often assumed to be elegiac, his story cycle Winesburg, Ohio, published in 1919, presents “a community of grotesques, of frustrated individuals who have repressed their life’s impulses and free spirits in order to survive.” By 1940, he’d collaborated on the photo book Home Town, providing the text to accompany pictures of rural life commissioned by the Department of Agriculture’s Farm Security Administration. The Anderson of Winesburg implicitly endorses a young main character’s flight from the closed-minded village to the liberation of the big city; near the end of his life, the Anderson of Home Town exhorts the reader with “a burning desire to remake life, the whole social scheme” to “try thinking small” instead, seeing as “the big world outside now is so filled with confusion.”

